Skip to product information
1 of 6

Our Most Popular - Top Favorite Mix

Our Most Popular - Top Favorite Mix

Regular price $15.95
Regular price Sale price $15.95
Sale Sold out
gluten free tree nuts free secure checkout BBB Member Happiness Guarantee

This is our most popular taffy flavor!  It's not just one flavor but rather a mix of the most popular 22 available flavors and it out sells every other single flavor 2 to 1.  Why?  Because although most people have a favorite flavor, most folks enjoy the variety and surprise that comes in this bag.  You know you will get a good flavor because by vote all of these are very popular!  So let us do the choosing for you and enjoy this variety packed bag!


P.S. This is also available in sugar free.

P.S.S.  If you really want to choose your own flavor try the Single Flavor Snack/Gift pack box, or the Pick a Flavor Assorted Snack/Gift Pack box under the ONE TIME Box product selection. 

P.S.S.S. If you like the really weird flavors and want something different...chances are we have that too, but delivery may be a bit longer - reach out to our team if you are looking for a specific flavor.


Our taffy is gluten free and tree nut free so it’s a great choice for those who have celiac or are allergic to nuts. Our taffy does contain egg whites and evaporated milk.
Ingredients: Corn syrup, sugar, palm oil, egg whites, evaporated mild, cocoa, molasses, sea salt, magic acid, citric acid, soy lecithin, natural & artificial flavor, artificial color (including FD&C blue#1, Red #3 & 40, yellow #5 & 6)

Allergy Info

Our taffy is allergy friendly - gluten free and tree nut free. It does contain milk and eggs. The shelf life of taffy is 6+ months so you have plenty of time to enjoy it. Remember taffy is temperature sensitive, so always store at warm or cool to room temperature to fully enjoy the flavors.


USA subscription boxes are charged $5.99-$8.99, depending on the box you order. Other store items' shipping rates are based on weight and size. You have the option to select your preferred shipping method and carrier at checkout.

Smile Guarantee

If you're not happy wer'e not happy. Reach out to us and we promise to make it right and have you smiling again.

View full details

Customer Reviews

Based on 6 reviews
Dawn S.

This is a xmas gift l can't wait to see what the person receiving thinks. I get a sample in my craft box with the Ruffled Daisy every month and I love it


My grandkids and the kids at my church loved them. They are always asking for more.

Richard G.

Very good! Next month I would like to order some chocolate, but I live in Tucson Arizona and the last time I ordered chocolate thru the mail it was melted. Maybe I wil have to wait till next winter loll

Patricia M.

This experience was AMAZING!! Their taffy is highly addicting and so delicious! We enjoyed the box of chosen flavors and had so much fun trying other flavors in the mixed flavor bag! You will not be disappointed!!

Amy W.

Best taffy ever!!!!