Couldn't load pickup availability
Your favorites, every month.
You already know what you love. Now get it delivered to your door every month — no surprises, no guessing, just your favorite taffy flavors, on repeat.
How it works:
- Choose your 3 favorite flavors from our 22 top fan-favorites
- Your box ships every month with exactly what you picked
- Want to switch things up? Just email hello@taffy2you.com with the subject line CHANGE MY FLAVOR by the 15th of the month and we'll update your next box
Choose your subscription:
- 3 Bags — You Choose All 3 ($29/month): Pick every flavor. Your box, your way.
- 3 Bags + Fan Favorites Bag ($35/month): Your 3 choice bags plus one bag of our most-loved fan-favorite flavors — a great way to find your next favorite.
Each bag is 5.3 oz of fresh, real-flavor taffy — made the way it's supposed to taste.
100% Freshness Guaranteed.
Ingredients
Ingredients
Our taffy is gluten free and tree nut free so it’s a great choice for those who have celiac or are allergic to nuts. Our taffy does contain egg whites and evaporated milk.
Ingredients: Corn syrup, sugar, palm oil, egg whites, evaporated mild, cocoa, molasses, sea salt, magic acid, citric acid, soy lecithin, natural & artificial flavor, artificial color (including FD&C blue#1, Red #3 & 40, yellow #5 & 6)
Allergy Info
Allergy Info
Our taffy is allergy friendly - gluten free and tree nut free. It does contain milk and eggs. The shelf life of taffy is 6+ months so you have plenty of time to enjoy it. Remember taffy is temperature sensitive, so always store at warm or cool to room temperature to fully enjoy the flavors.
Shipping
Shipping
USA subscription boxes are charged $5.99-$8.99, depending on the box you order. Other store items' shipping rates are based on weight and size. You have the option to select your preferred shipping method and carrier at checkout.
Smile Guarantee
Smile Guarantee
If you're not happy wer'e not happy. Reach out to us and we promise to make it right and have you smiling again.
